[XTREM] walter3kurtz Players 1,037 posts 10,815 battles Report post #101 Posted May 17, 2017 Z: 17 Midway (2/1/2): 18 Henry IV 16 Grozovoi : 16 Des Moines: 28 Gearing: 24 -3 = 21 Why play her if you have Fletcher? Hakuryu (2/3/2): 21 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20 Hakuryu (2/3/3): 23 Yamato: 24 + 1 = 25 She has nice big guns and I get to play with them Zao: 27 Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 15 Hindenburg: 25 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 21 G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20 Moskva: 23 Khabarovsk: 23 Minotaur: 11 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ulysses_nemo Players 502 posts 14,453 battles Report post #102 Posted May 18, 2017 Daily vote : Z: 17-3=14 Midway (2/1/2): 18 Henry IV 16 Grozovoi : 16 Des Moines: 28+1= 29 Gearing: 21 Hakuryu (2/3/2): 21 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20 Hakuryu (2/3/3): 23 Yamato: 25 Zao: 27 Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 15 Hindenburg: 25 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 21 G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20 Moskva: 23 Khabarovsk: 23 Minotaur: 11 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ulysses_nemo Players 502 posts 14,453 battles Report post #103 Posted May 19, 2017 Daily vote : Z: 14-3=11 Midway (2/1/2): 18 Henry IV 16 Grozovoi : 16 Des Moines: 29+1= 30 Gearing: 21 Hakuryu (2/3/2): 21 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20 Hakuryu (2/3/3): 23 Yamato: 25 Zao: 27 Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 15 Hindenburg: 25 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 21 G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20 Moskva: 23 Khabarovsk: 23 Minotaur: 11 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ulysses_nemo Players 502 posts 14,453 battles Report post #104 Posted May 22, 2017 Daily vote, let's finish this : Z: 11-3 = 8 Midway (2/1/2): 18 Henry IV 16 Grozovoi : 16 Des Moines: 30+1= 31 Gearing: 21 Hakuryu (2/3/2): 21 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20 Hakuryu (2/3/3): 23 Yamato: 25 Zao: 27 Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 15 Hindenburg: 25 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 21 G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20 Moskva: 23 Khabarovsk: 23 Minotaur: 11 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ulysses_nemo Players 502 posts 14,453 battles Report post #105 Posted May 23, 2017 Last time I bump this subject if I'm the only voter. Z: 8-3 = 5 Midway (2/1/2): 18Henry IV 16 Grozovoi : 16 Des Moines: 31+1= 32Gearing: 21 Hakuryu (2/3/2): 21 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20Hakuryu (2/3/3): 23Yamato: 25 Zao: 27Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 15Hindenburg: 25 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 21G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20Moskva: 23Khabarovsk: 23Minotaur: 11 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
dCK_Ad_Hominem Players 1,176 posts 5,859 battles Report post #106 Posted June 24, 2017 Z: 8-3 = 5 Midway (2/1/2): 18 Henry IV 16 Grozovoi : 16 Des Moines: 31+1= 32 Gearing: 21 Hakuryu (2/3/2): 21 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20 Hakuryu (2/3/3): 23 Yamato: 25 Zao: 27 Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 15 + 1 = 16 Hindenburg: 25 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 21 G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20 Moskva: 23 Khabarovsk: 23 Minotaur: 11 - 3 = 8. Powerful, but a one trick pony. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
_HomTanks_ Players 3,368 posts 37,429 battles Report post #107 Posted June 24, 2017 Z: 8-3 = 5Midway (2/1/2): 18Henry IV 16 Grozovoi : 16 Des Moines: 31+1= 32Gearing: 21 - 3 = 18 (Fletcher is more fun, it is weak against T8-9-10 Soviet DDs, good against IJN but any dd is good against IJN in a knife-fight. There is no such thing as all rounder. All-rounder means it's not very good at or it doesn't excel in anything and a good ship must have at least one excellent characteristics of its own, imo.)Hakuryu (2/3/2): 21 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20Hakuryu (2/3/3): 23Yamato: 25 Zao: 27Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 15 + 1 = 16Hindenburg: 25 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 21G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20Moskva: 23Khabarovsk: 23 + 1= 24 (Best DD/light cruiser, very fun to play with and dmg maker, game influencer)Minotaur: 11 - 3 = 8. Powerful, but a one trick pony. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[NWP] 159Hunter Players 4,528 posts Report post #108 Posted June 24, 2017 Z: 8-3 = 5Midway (2/1/2): 18Henry IV 16 Grozovoi : 16 Des Moines: 32+1=33 Just a nice all rounderGearing: 18 Hakuryu (2/3/2): 21 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20Hakuryu (2/3/3): 23Yamato: 25 Zao: 27Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 16Hindenburg: 25 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 21G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20Moskva: 23Khabarovsk: 24Minotaur: 8-3=5 Can be so frustrating from time to time Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ulysses_nemo Players 502 posts 14,453 battles Report post #109 Posted June 25, 2017 Z: 5-3 = 2Midway (2/1/2): 18Henry IV 16 Grozovoi : 16 Des Moines: 33+1=34Gearing: 18 Hakuryu (2/3/2): 21 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20Hakuryu (2/3/3): 23Yamato: 25 Zao: 27Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 16Hindenburg: 25 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 21G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20Moskva: 23Khabarovsk: 24Minotaur: 5 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[BLITZ] WeGreedy Players 3,005 posts 14,954 battles Report post #110 Posted June 26, 2017 Z: 5-3 = 2Midway (2/1/2): 18Henry IV: 16 Grozovoi: 16 Des Moines: 34Gearing: 18 Hakuryu (2/3/2): 21 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20Hakuryu (2/3/3): 23Yamato: 25 Zao: 27Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 16Hindenburg: 25 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 21G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20Moskva: 23Khabarovsk: 24+1=25 speed tanking ftw, very thrilling gameplayMinotaur: 5 Gearing would get my -3 but I have not played her in current patch. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ulysses_nemo Players 502 posts 14,453 battles Report post #111 Posted June 26, 2017 You need to give a -3 to a ship. That's the only way to eliminate ships. Give it to the Gearing if you don't like her, even if it was before patch. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RenamedUser_92906789 Players 5,828 posts Report post #112 Posted June 26, 2017 Just to make this going I am going to vote even I dont have a single t10 ship. So my vote will be very "subjective" based on the information i gathered from the net (and yes, I watch all the vids from the main youtubers). Z: 5-3 = 2Midway (2/1/2): 18Henry IV: 16 Grozovoi: 16 Des Moines: 34 + 1 = 35 (Just because I love the Cleveland, and this looks like his big brother)Gearing: 15 (alredy included SeeTaufels vote) Hakuryu (2/3/2): 21 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20Hakuryu (2/3/3): 23Yamato: 25 Zao: 27Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 16 - 3 = 13. (Currently when facing them they do not intimidate me one bit...)Hindenburg: 25 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 21G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20Moskva: 23Khabarovsk: 25Minotaur: 5 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[SLOTH] txtspeak Players 3,041 posts 5,653 battles Report post #113 Posted June 26, 2017 Z: 5-3 = 2Midway (2/1/2): 18Henry IV: 16 Grozovoi: 16 Des Moines: 35+1=36 (I utterly love this ship, it kicks ALL the asses!)Gearing: 15-3=12 (Fletcher is just better fullstop) Hakuryu (2/3/2): 21 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20Hakuryu (2/3/3): 23Yamato: 25 Zao: 27Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 13Hindenburg: 25 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 21G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20Moskva: 23Khabarovsk: 25Minotaur: 5 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[BLITZ] WeGreedy Players 3,005 posts 14,954 battles Report post #114 Posted June 26, 2017 19 hours ago, ulysses_nemo said: You need to give a -3 to a ship. That's the only way to eliminate ships. Give it to the Gearing if you don't like her, even if it was before patch. On 1.11.2016 at 11:03 PM, who_dares_wins said: Rules: 3: You must have played tier 10 in the current patch. No exceptions. Just tried to follow the rules. nambrnein already included my -3, thanks mate. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[XODUS] JaiFoh Players 799 posts 4,868 battles Report post #115 Posted June 26, 2017 Z: 2Midway (2/1/2): 18Henry IV: 16 Grozovoi: 16 Des Moines: 36 Gearing: 12-3= 9 I just don't see the point in upgrading personally i love my Fletcher even though everyone shoots it without hesitation Hakuryu (2/3/2): 21 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20Hakuryu (2/3/3): 23Yamato: 25 Zao: 27Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 13Hindenburg: 25 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 21G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20Moskva: 23Khabarovsk: 25Minotaur: 5+1=6 Still a Beast and with team support can be an utter monster Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ulysses_nemo Players 502 posts 14,453 battles Report post #116 Posted June 26, 2017 4 minutes ago, SeeteufeI said: Just tried to follow the rules. nambr9 already included my -3, thanks mate. I changed the rule when I unearthed that post a few months ago since there was way not enough voters for those. I changed it to : You have to have played them (no reference to patch) or played against (so if you play tier 8, 9, 10). 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[BLITZ] WeGreedy Players 3,005 posts 14,954 battles Report post #117 Posted June 27, 2017 Z: 2Midway (2/1/2): 18Henry IV: 16 Grozovoi: 16 Des Moines: 36 Gearing: 9-3=6 imo she is actually a torpboat, better torps than shima (reaction time). In cqc guns are quite good against DDs, but there are not many situations like that. She also lacks speed. Hakuryu (2/3/2): 21 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20Hakuryu (2/3/3): 23Yamato: 25 Zao: 27Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 13Hindenburg: 25 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 21G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20Moskva: 23Khabarovsk: 25Minotaur: 6+1=7 very unforgiving, but also very fun to play *pewpewpew Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
belecrider Players 28 posts 2,991 battles Report post #118 Posted June 27, 2017 Z: 2Midway (2/1/2): 18Henry IV: 16 Grozovoi: 16 Des Moines: 36 Gearing: 6+1=7 more guns, better torps, same handling as fletcher, whats not to love? Hakuryu (2/3/2): 21 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20Hakuryu (2/3/3): 23Yamato: 25 Zao: 27Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 13Hindenburg: 25 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 21G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20Moskva: 23Khabarovsk: 25Minotaur: 7-3=4 just not as scary as it seams to be, eats citadels from any angle, easy to blind shot in smoke. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[TFLM] axe9920 Players 7 posts 10,658 battles Report post #119 Posted July 5, 2017 Z: 2Midway (2/1/2): 18Henry IV: 16 Grozovoi: 16 Des Moines: 36 Gearing: 7 - 3 = 4 (Love the Fletcher, but this worse in every meaningful way, so can't be the winner) Hakuryu (2/3/2): 21 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20Hakuryu (2/3/3): 23Yamato: 25 +1 = 26 (Knowing that if you get your shot just right, someone else is going to be screaming at their monitor)Zao: 27Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 13Hindenburg: 25 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 21G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20Moskva: 23Khabarovsk: 25Minotaur: 4 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[XODUS] JaiFoh Players 799 posts 4,868 battles Report post #120 Posted July 5, 2017 Z: 2Midway (2/1/2): 18Henry IV: 16 Grozovoi: 16 Des Moines: 36 Gearing: 4 - 3 = 1 (The Fletcher just seems so much better and i see more Fletchers than Gearings ) Hakuryu (2/3/2): 21 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20Hakuryu (2/3/3): 23Yamato: 26Zao: 27Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 13Hindenburg: 25 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 21G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20Moskva: 23Khabarovsk: 25Minotaur: 4 +1 = 5 (Had so much fun the other day with a Fletcher holding a flank and inflicting 170k plus damage even when firing in the open) Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
