[XTREM] walter3kurtz Players 1,037 posts 10,815 battles Report post #26 Posted November 3, 2016 Nice thread, too little votes. So keep it coming no-lifers! Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[CATCH] DDMafiaAssociateMember Players 433 posts 6,031 battles Report post #27 Posted November 3, 2016 Bump Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
anonym_EFwxJOPWzlER Players 1,473 posts Report post #28 Posted November 3, 2016 (edited) Midway (2/1/2): 21 Midway (3/0/2): 11-3=8 - reasons should be pretty obvious to anyone with experience with CVs Midway (1/2/2): 20 Montana: 8 Des Moines: 20 Gearing: 21+1=22 (Best DD in the game) Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20 Hakuryu (2/3/3): 20 Yamato: 21 Zao: 26 Shimakaze (Long lances): 11-3=8 (Why oh why do WG bother giving us such crap in the game) Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 20 Shimakaze (type F3): 20 Hindenburg: 20+1=21 - same HE dpm and FPM as Zao, insane AP dpm, very good range, amazing AA G. Kurfürst (406mm): 21 G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20 Moskva: 21 Khabarovsk: 20 Khabarovsk (ET-46): 20 Minotaur: 17 Edited November 3, 2016 by anonym_EFwxJOPWzlER Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[PRAVD] duoinvasion Players 390 posts 9,058 battles Report post #29 Posted November 3, 2016 Midway (2/1/2): 21 Midway (3/0/2): 11-3=8 - reasons should be pretty obvious to anyone with experience with CVs Midway (1/2/2): 20 Montana: 8 Des Moines: 20 Gearing: 21+1=22 (Best DD in the game) Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20 Hakuryu (2/3/3): 20 Yamato: 21 Zao: 26 Shimakaze (Long lances): 11-3=8 (Why oh why do WG bother giving us such crap in the game) Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 20 Shimakaze (type F3): 20 Hindenburg: 20+1=21 - same HE dpm and FPM as Zao, insane AP dpm, very good range, amazing AA G. Kurfürst (406mm): 21 G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20 Moskva: 21 Khabarovsk: 20 Khabarovsk (ET-46): 20 Minotaur: 17 I mean how do miss copy pasting the last list? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
anonym_EFwxJOPWzlER Players 1,473 posts Report post #30 Posted November 4, 2016 I mean how do miss copy pasting the last list? Because i went to Specsavers ! Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[CATCH] DDMafiaAssociateMember Players 433 posts 6,031 battles Report post #31 Posted November 4, 2016 Midway (2/1/2): 21 Midway (3/0/2): 2 Midway (1/2/2): 20 Montana: 5 Des Moines: 20 Gearing: 22+1=23(Best DD in the game) Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20 Hakuryu (2/3/3): 20 Yamato: 21 Zao: 27 Shimakaze (Long lances): 8-3=5 (Why oh why do WG bother giving us such crap in the game) Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 20 Shimakaze (type F3): 20 Hindenburg: 22 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 22 G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20 Moskva: 21 Khabarovsk: 21 Khabarovsk (ET-46): 17 Minotaur: 17 Fixed it for you 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[CAG] General_Alexus Players 1,046 posts 13,178 battles Report post #32 Posted November 4, 2016 Pls try to copy the last post and doublecheck, you missed my Khaba Vote eg, or the G Kurfürst with 22 Points. Midway (2/1/2): 21 Midway (3/0/2): 2 Midway (1/2/2): 20 Montana: 5 Des Moines: 20 Gearing: 23 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20 Hakuryu (2/3/3): 20 Yamato: 21 Zao: 26 Shimakaze (Long lances): 5 Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 20 Shimakaze (type F3): 20 Hindenburg: 22 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 22 G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20 Moskva: 21 Khabarovsk: 20 Khabarovsk (ET-46): 17 Minotaur: 17 I hope i didnt overlooked something. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[CATCH] DDMafiaAssociateMember Players 433 posts 6,031 battles Report post #33 Posted November 4, 2016 Pls try to copy the last post and doublecheck, you missed my Khaba Vote eg, or the G Kurfürst with 22 Points. Midway (2/1/2): 21 Midway (3/0/2): 2 Midway (1/2/2): 20 Montana: 5 Des Moines: 20 Gearing: 23 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20 Hakuryu (2/3/3): 20 Yamato: 21 Zao: 26 Shimakaze (Long lances): 5 Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 20 Shimakaze (type F3): 20 Hindenburg: 22 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 22 G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20 Moskva: 21 Khabarovsk: 20 Khabarovsk (ET-46): 17 Minotaur: 17 I hope i didnt overlooked something. Whoops. Fixed. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Kurbain Players 1,976 posts 2,773 battles Report post #34 Posted November 4, 2016 Midway (2/1/2): 21 Midway (3/0/2): 2 - 2 = 0 (Time for AS Midway to say goodbye) Midway (1/2/2): 20 Montana: 5 Des Moines: 20 Gearing: 23 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20 Hakuryu (2/3/3): 20 + 1 = 21 (Unless you are in a DM or Hindenburg, don't expect to survive if a good Hakuryu player wants you dead) Yamato: 21 Zao: 26 Shimakaze (Long lances): 5 Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 20 Shimakaze (type F3): 20 Hindenburg: 22 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 22 G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20 Moskva: 21 Khabarovsk: 20 Khabarovsk (ET-46): 17 Minotaur: 17 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[CAG] General_Alexus Players 1,046 posts 13,178 battles Report post #35 Posted November 5, 2016 (edited) Midway (2/1/2): 21 Midway (1/1/3): 20+1=21 ( there is only a 113 Midway, but even if it´s not 1 2 2 it´s still playable ) Montana: 5 Des Moines: 20 Gearing: 23 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20 Hakuryu (2/3/3): 21 Yamato: 21 Zao: 26 Shimakaze (Long lances): 5 Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 20 Shimakaze (type F3): 20 Hindenburg: 22 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 22 G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20 Moskva: 21 Khabarovsk: 21 ( I forget correct this number as well ) Khabarovsk (ET-46): 17-3=14 ( i voted for it alredy, i mean do you knoiw somebody even paying 2kk+ Credits for this crap? ) Minotaur: 17 Edited November 5, 2016 by General_Alexus Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[PN4VY] utg001 Players 50 posts 11,586 battles Report post #36 Posted November 5, 2016 Midway (2/1/2): 21 Midway (1/1/3): 21 Montana: 5 Des Moines: 20+1=21 (Queen of cruisers my [edited], this is the king. the insane rof negates any other con (torps), use concealment to ambush) Gearing: 23 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20 Hakuryu (2/3/3): 21 Yamato: 21 Zao: 26 Shimakaze (Long lances): 5-3=2 (because obvious) Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 20 Shimakaze (type F3): 20 Hindenburg: 22 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 22 G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20 Moskva: 21 Khabarovsk: 21 Khabarovsk (ET-46): 14 Minotaur: 17 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[OM-S] Kann_Nix_Extreme Players 388 posts 15,432 battles Report post #37 Posted November 5, 2016 Midway (2/1/2): 21 Midway (1/1/3): 21 Montana: 5 Des Moines: 21 Gearing: 23 Hakuryu (2/3/2): 20 + 1 = 21 You forgot to include the Hakus stock loadout, which is the best IMO, since giving up one DB squad is totally worth the extra reserve space you gain for your TBs Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20 Hakuryu (2/3/3): 21 Yamato: 21 Zao: 26 Shimakaze (Long lances): 2 Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 20 Shimakaze (type F3): 20 Hindenburg: 22 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 22 G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20 Moskva: 21 Khabarovsk: 21 Khabarovsk (ET-46): 14 - 3 = 11 The stock torps are at least usable Minotaur: 17 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[PANEU] kfa Beta Tester 1,975 posts 13,875 battles Report post #38 Posted November 5, 2016 (edited) Midway (2/1/2): 21 Midway (1/1/3): 21 Montana: 5 Des Moines: 21 Gearing: 23 Hakuryu (2/3/2): 21 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20 Hakuryu (2/3/3): 21 + 1 = 22 I dont agree with you Kann_nix, the stock loadout is not better. The games almost never last so long that you actually need extra TBs (or you might run out at 14-16 minutes, but the battle is already over at that point, lost or won), but you always need those clustered up 15 DBs to set fires. 2 DB squads really suffer when trying to set multiple fires on a Montana/Kurfürst. Tried it, didnt like it. Yamato: 22 She lost a point somewhere, fixed it for you. Zao: 26 Shimakaze (Long lances): 2 - 3 Eliminated. It wasnt really a question but i was surprised that the montana and Midway are still there. Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 20 Shimakaze (type F3): 20 Hindenburg: 22 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 22 G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20 Moskva: 21 Khabarovsk: 21 Khabarovsk (ET-46): 11 Minotaur: 17 Edited November 5, 2016 by kfa Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
cro_pwr Players 2,735 posts 10,310 battles Report post #39 Posted November 5, 2016 Could you post your oppinions and comments somewhere else then in the table so we have a clean table to copy/paste and to check for scores / mistakes easier? Midway (2/1/2): 21 Midway (1/1/3): 21 Montana: 5 Des Moines: 21 +1 = 22 Gearing: 23 Hakuryu (2/3/2): 21 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20 Hakuryu (2/3/3): 22 Yamato: 22 Zao: 26 Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 20 Shimakaze (type F3): 20 Hindenburg: 22 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 22 G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20 Moskva: 21 Khabarovsk: 21 Khabarovsk (ET-46): 11 - 3 = 8 Minotaur: 17 Why would you like to loose range and speed on your 10km torps is beyond me, so -3 points for that, and +1 for Des Moines. The ability to pump out so much damage to even rip appart t10 battleships in a minute is scary Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[CATCH] DDMafiaAssociateMember Players 433 posts 6,031 battles Report post #40 Posted November 5, 2016 Shameless bump (again) 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[NWP] Gojuadorai Players 2,832 posts 21,712 battles Report post #41 Posted November 5, 2016 Midway (2/1/2): 21 Midway (1/1/3): 21 Montana: 5 Des Moines: 21 Gearing: 23 Hakuryu (2/3/2): 21 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20 Hakuryu (2/3/3): 22 Yamato: 22+1=23 Zao: 26 Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 20 Shimakaze (type F3): 20-3=17 Hindenburg: 22 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 22 G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20 Moskva: 21 Khabarovsk: 21 Khabarovsk (ET-46): 11 Minotaur: 17 8 km on shima torps well lets face it its a gimmick nobody would run it in a serious battle yamato is still the best t10 bb so why not how often you may vote (players vots in between yours? cause i doubt we get a elimination without doubble votes) Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[WGP2W] Namolis Players 751 posts 18,410 battles Report post #42 Posted November 6, 2016 Montana: 5-3=2 (time to get rid of her) Moskva: 21+1=22 (Those guns...) Midway (2/1/2): 21 Midway (1/1/3): 21 Montana: 2 Des Moines: 21 Gearing: 23 Hakuryu (2/3/2): 21 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20 Hakuryu (2/3/3): 22 Yamato: 22+1=23 Zao: 26 Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 20 Shimakaze (type F3): 20-3=17 Hindenburg: 22 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 22 G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20 Moskva: 22 Khabarovsk: 21 Khabarovsk (ET-46): 11 Minotaur: 17 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[OM-S] Kann_Nix_Extreme Players 388 posts 15,432 battles Report post #43 Posted November 6, 2016 Midway (2/1/2): 21 Midway (1/1/3): 21 Montana: 2 Des Moines: 21 Gearing: 23 Hakuryu (2/3/2): 21 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20 Hakuryu (2/3/3): 22 Yamato: 23 Zao: 26 Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 20 Shimakaze (type F3): 17 Hindenburg: 22 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 22 G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20 Moskva: 22 Khabarovsk: 22 Khabarovsk (ET-46): 8 Minotaur: 17 Khabarovsk +1 = 22 A fun ship, even after the nerf ET-46 -3 = 8 But not with those torps @Gojuadorai: I guess once every 24 ish hours should be fine Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[DJMDK] Fionia_DK Players 173 posts 17,112 battles Report post #44 Posted November 6, 2016 Midway (2/1/2): 21 Midway (1/1/3): 21 Montana: 2 Des Moines: 21 Gearing: 23 Hakuryu (2/3/2): 21 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20 Hakuryu (2/3/3): 22 Yamato: 23 Zao: 26 Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 21 (20+1) In a good game you can make a ton of damage, without getting spottet at all. Shimakaze (type F3): 17 Hindenburg: 22 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 22 G. Kurfürst (420mm): 20 Moskva: 22 Khabarovsk: 22 Khabarovsk (ET-46): 5 (8-3) Nerfed and terrible torps. Minotaur: 17 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[TTTX] Tyrendian89 [TTTX] Players 4,608 posts 8,139 battles Report post #45 Posted November 6, 2016 Midway (2/1/2): 21 Midway (1/1/3): 21 Montana: 0 (2-3 let's give the poor thing its mercy kill - sadly not up to par with its direct competitors) Des Moines: 21 Gearing: 23 Hakuryu (2/3/2): 21 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20 Hakuryu (2/3/3): 22 Yamato: 23 Zao: 26 Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 21 Shimakaze (type F3): 17 Hindenburg: 22 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 22 G. Kurfürst (420mm): 21 (20+1 because DANK 420s YO!) Moskva: 22 Khabarovsk: 22 Khabarovsk (ET-46): 5 Minotaur: 17 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[WG] MrConway WG Staff, Alpha Tester 3,411 posts 4,389 battles Report post #46 Posted November 6, 2016 Midway (2/1/2): 21 Midway (1/1/3): 21 Des Moines: 21 Gearing: 23 Hakuryu (2/3/2): 21 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20 Hakuryu (2/3/3): 22 Yamato: 23 Zao: 27 (+1 for laser accuracy!) Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 21 Shimakaze (type F3): 17 Hindenburg: 22 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 21 (-1 why would you even, seriously!) G. Kurfürst (420mm): 21 Moskva: 22 Khabarovsk: 22 Khabarovsk (ET-46): 5 Minotaur: 17 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[OM-S] Kann_Nix_Extreme Players 388 posts 15,432 battles Report post #47 Posted November 6, 2016 These are the current scores after removing MrConways remaining 2 points from the 406mm Kurfürst Midway (2/1/2): 21 Midway (1/1/3): 21 Des Moines: 21 Gearing: 23 Hakuryu (2/3/2): 21 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20 Hakuryu (2/3/3): 22 Yamato: 23 Zao: 27 Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 21 Shimakaze (type F3): 17 Hindenburg: 22 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 19 G. Kurfürst (420mm): 21 Moskva: 22 Khabarovsk: 22 Khabarovsk (ET-46): 5 Minotaur: 17 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[GRNPA] avenger121 Beta Tester 1,296 posts 10,330 battles Report post #48 Posted November 6, 2016 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 21 (-1 why would you even, seriously!) Because the 406mm guns have up to ~ 11-12km more penetration, together with the MBM3 you can push your RoF to 2.4 which means you have by far the highest SPM from all T10 BBs. It is a viable choice. The loss of 800 dmg per cit and 1mm less overmatch is negligible. 2 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[PRAVD] duoinvasion Players 390 posts 9,058 battles Report post #49 Posted November 6, 2016 Midway (2/1/2): 21 Midway (1/1/3): 8 Des Moines: 21 Gearing: 23 Hakuryu (2/3/2): 21 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20 Hakuryu (2/3/3): 22 Yamato: 23 Zao: 27 Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 21 Shimakaze (type F3): 17 Hindenburg: 22 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 19 G. Kurfürst (420mm): 22 Moskva: 22 Khabarovsk: 22 Khabarovsk (ET-46): 5 Minotaur: 17 212midway is better cause those 2 fighters are a huge assetdank 420 yo is obv Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[OM-S] Kann_Nix_Extreme Players 388 posts 15,432 battles Report post #50 Posted November 7, 2016 Midway (2/1/2): 18 Midway (1/1/3): 9 Des Moines: 21 Gearing: 23 Hakuryu (2/3/2): 21 Hakuryu (4/2/2): 20 Hakuryu (2/3/3): 22 Yamato: 23 Zao: 27 Shimakaze (type 93 mod. 2): 21 Shimakaze (type F3): 17 Hindenburg: 22 G. Kurfürst (406mm): 19 G. Kurfürst (420mm): 22 Moskva: 22 Khabarovsk: 22 Khabarovsk (ET-46): 5 Minotaur: 17 Don't really agree with that Midway thing. IMO one should go full strike, since 14 fighters are a bit over the top to counter the Hakus ones. Also I allways felt the need to have 3 DBs. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
