again: the unsportsmalike conduct does not work correct!

[hellhound666]

15 minutes ago, MementoMori_6030 said:

I am tempted to create an account for my pets and let them try to outperform him. 

i will report you for animal cruelty and not just here ...

[Andrewbassg]

1 hour ago, NewHorizons_1 said:

What I would consider an unfair penalty is when a lone destroyer runs away and hides behind an island to run the clock down and win on points.

 There the correct thing is to do NOTHING and not die.

That's a very good point. Still if he Alt tabbed out during that period........hmmm..

[Karasu_Browarszky]

2 hours ago, MementoMori_6030 said:

While I would not say that he has done nothing, his performance above T5 is so poor that maybe the system has decided that he is sabotaging the game on purpose. And who knows how many of his shots/torpedoes have hit allies...

 

Somehow I don't think that can be it....

[Saltface]

Kagero with 0 spotted ribbons - wondering how the DD with the best concealment in that game did not spot anything all game

 

[lup3s]

8 hours ago, Saltface said:

Kagero with 0 spotted ribbons - wondering how the DD with the best concealment in that game did not spot anything all game

 

 

Technically possible if there's a CV or some overly aggressive FR DD captains 

[Saltface]

4 minutes ago, lup3s said:

Technically possible if there's a CV or some overly aggressive FR DD captains

and the CV scouts your side and the FR DD plays in front of you OR lex parsimoniae (Occam's Razor) passive play AF.

 

 

[NewHorizons_1]

Interestingly, my router decided to wedge itself right at the start of a co-op match.

By the time I got back in, there were only two bots left and both out of range **.

Every stat was zero apart from the 6min 2sec duration, 12.2km distance travelled and spotting one plane.

Even then I didn't get a pink unsportsman penalty, and for added giggles my T9 Georgia made a 7.8k credit profit on a standard (non-premium) account.

So, it does seem a little odd that people who have dome something get tagged.

I suppose a random battle is going to be different (because of the longer match duration) so I guess there's more time for alleged inactivity to occur.

 

** I possibly could have stole a kill on a low health cruiser with the spotter plane up, but I didn't want to steal the kill (from those that had earned it) and also wanted to see if I'd trigger the AFK

[SurfaceFish]

13 hours ago, Saltface said:

Kagero with 0 spotted ribbons - wondering how the DD with the best concealment in that game did not spot anything all game

 

Needs to buy a new keyboard where the "W" and "S" are in the correct position. 

[PaP_Mentoles]

Ehm...

What is working correct is this shiteshow? This "game" should be renamed in World of Bugs and Planes

[Karkong_the_Impaler]

Ok. Again. Maybe I was being unclear:

 

It's a troll. It relishes in up the game for other players:

 @Daughter_of_the_Dawn is apparently also one of its accounts, but just look at the name on the screenshot - it's it:

And if you want to see its playstyle, just watch the replay:

 

Apparently it tries to skirt the absolute minimum requirements to not get relegated to coop. And it still is able to play and also troll the forums? Why on earth isn't it banned, everywhere? With all its accounts?

 

@Seraphice

@YabbaCoe

Anyone?

 

 

[SurfaceFish]

CO OP battle, the only bot BB on our side sailed all way from our flank to the other side. So I quite the battle when I have no chance to get to the red ships left to do damage. Why should I get penalised if WG can't programme their bot to match players position.

 

Why WG make the slow bot BB change flank when there is a BB on our flank, this happens more and more now in CO OP, why @Seraphice?

 

The next game, a bot DD stuck to the island all game, if a ship from other side of the map quite the battle early because of this, why should that player suffer for WG's incompetence?

 

But admit no fault and blame the players will be my guess from WG's response.

 

[Aitvars]

Can you provide the replay? Screenshots cant tell, what lead to the penalty. And so dont do the stories of the punished. 

[SurfaceFish]

18 minutes ago, Aitvars said:

Can you provide the replay? Screenshots cant tell, what lead to the penalty. And so dont do the stories of the punished. 

 

I left the game around 4:30 mins, the game lasted 6:30 mins. It's co op, so the rewards don't matter, but WG bot pathfinding has been atrocious in co op and some operations this patch. Trust WG to take whats was working and "fixing" it.

20230305_105532_PASD005-Farragut-1944_17_NA_fault_line.wowsreplay

[Karkong_the_Impaler]

15 minutes ago, SurfaceFish said:

I left the game around 4:30 mins, the game lasted 6:30 mins.

As in "alt tab" or as in "esc - do you really wish to leave the game?"

[Aitvars]

Vor 25 Minuten, SurfaceFish sagte:

 

I left the game around 4:30 mins, the game lasted 6:30 mins. It's co op, so the rewards don't matter, but WG bot pathfinding has been atrocious in co op and some operations this patch. Trust WG to take whats was working and "fixing" it.

20230305_105532_PASD005-Farragut-1944_17_NA_fault_line.wowsreplay

so you admit, you left the game? and the replay "suddenly" ends, while you where in range of shooting a BB (not the gneisenau leaving your side, which you claimed in your story, but the incoming mackensen from middle)? what other outcome do you expect from such behaviour than being punished?

[Captain_Lootbox]

On 3/3/2023 at 11:11 AM, Why_Cant_I_Be_You said:

just look at the screenshot !! That is unsportsmanlike ??

 

 

I see the problem.  Someone thought you were play a sub and reported you by mistake.

[SurfaceFish]

21 minutes ago, Karkong_the_Impaler said:

As in "alt tab" or as in "esc - do you really wish to leave the game?"

Yes, so I can play another co op game. I don't want to sit and watch the game where I can't make much difference. It is already won.

 

12 minutes ago, Aitvars said:

so you admit, you left the game? and the replay "suddenly" ends, while you where in range of shooting a BB (not the gneisenau leaving your side, which you claimed in your story, but the incoming mackensen from middle)? what other outcome do you expect from such behaviour than being punished?

There are 3 green ships in B so close that will kill that BB very quickly, what difference does it makes? Its a co op game, It made no difference to the outcome, I did my job at my flank against bots. US flotty shells with bad fire chance, I'm not going to shoot anything at max range in US DD. I feel sorry for the cruiser and BB behind me, they had hardly any ships to shoot at.

 

The question is should player be punished when their absence makes no difference near the end? Interestingly, in court its not enough to prove wrong doing, you need to prove the harm that was course by such action. 

 

BTW, I don't mind not receiving rewards for quitting game early. WG should get their bot pathfinding fixed ASAP, all bots seems to goto the center of the map this patch, so slow ships at flank just wasting their time in CO OP.

[Karkong_the_Impaler]

11 minutes ago, SurfaceFish said:

Yes, so I can play another co op game. I don't want to sit and watch the game where I can't make much difference. It is already won.

 

 

I have yet to see someone undeserving of that automated punishment thingy, apart maybe from that DD who got detonated first salvo in a coop match. I mean, even the german CV who thought it funny to kill the DD with secondaries alone actually deserved it, if alone for playing CV.

 

Edit: Your reasoning is ridiculous in the first place, because then you could leave a coop game right at the start. Because they're always won. For even shorter games.

[Aitvars]

Vor 8 Minuten, SurfaceFish sagte:

There are 3 green ships in B so close that will kill that BB very quickly, what difference does it makes? Its a co op game, It made no difference to the outcome, I did my job at my flank against bots. US flotty shells with bad fire chance, I'm not going to shoot anything at max range in US DD. I feel sorry for the cruiser and BB behind me, they had hardly any ships to shoot at.

so if there's no difference what are you complaining about? your behaviour met the conditions being punished and that's what happend. and obviously it's not a false positive.

[Captain_Lootbox]

3 minutes ago, Karkong_the_Impaler said:

 

 

I have yet to see someone undeserving of that automated punishment thingy, apart maybe from that DD who got detonated first salvo in a coop match. I mean, even the german CV who thought it funny to kill the DD with secondaries alone actually deserved it, if alone for playing CV.

 

Edit: Your reasoning is ridiculous in the first place, because then you could leave a coop game right at the start. Because they're always won. For even shorter games.

Well as long as you havent seen it then it didnt happen. Thansk for clearing that up.

[Karkong_the_Impaler]

1 minute ago, Aitvars said:

so if there's no difference what are you complaining about? your behaviour met the conditions being punished and that's what happend. and obviously it's not a false positive.

Even worse, he acknowledged that by leaving the match he will get punished. And then he complains about being punished. Srsly, is this an entitlement issue? Or an intellectual one? Or why would anyone think that he won't get punished?!

[Yosha_AtaIante]

1 minute ago, Karkong_the_Impaler said:

Even worse, he acknowledged that by leaving the match he will get punished. And then he complains about being punished. Srsly, is this an entitlement issue? Or an intellectual one? Or why would anyone think that he won't get punished?!

He just wants attention 

[SurfaceFish]

As usual ignoring WG poor implantation of bot pathfinding in my screenshots which decreases the co op experience, that is my compliant. 

[Yosha_AtaIante]

Just now, SurfaceFish said:

As usual ignoring WG poor implantation of bot pathing which decreases the co op experience. 

Dude imagine thinking coop ever was something worth experiencing. It's like shooting a wall in first person shooters. How can you have fun in that mode?

[Karkong_the_Impaler]

1 minute ago, Captain_Lootbox said:

Well as long as you havent seen it then it didnt happen. Thansk for clearing that up.

You're welcome.

But since you are intent on misinterpreting, I'll try to write slower:

I personally alt tab all the time, to check on obscure ship radar ranges and win rate of players with hidden stats, switch my music and whatnot and haven't been punished once. And anyone who came here and made a thread about this was never undeserving (apart from maybe these two I mentioned)