I get 'Inactivity in battle'

[Panzer_Guido]

3 minutes ago, KhorneFlake said:

Oh no...

Let me guess, he was ranting about the game afterwards for hours?

You know, He is a crybaby and he's not even a good Player either.

 

Don't watch his streams anymore, do something usefull like reading a book or finding a cure for cancer instead

i dont particularly like the guy, but sub 50% WR players claiming he is not a good player is ...funny to say the least. 

[KhorneFlake]

Never said I m a unicum.

Doesnt change the fact Flamu isnt good either.

Which would lead directly to you, having 14K more battles presenting mere 4% more win rate is nothing to be proud of

[159Hunter]

21 hours ago, Wild_Butter said:

I get 'Inactivity in battle' cuz I was killed by salvo from assault planes in first minute of battle wtf ?! what to do ? thats unfair

We're at page 3 and so far not a single forumite has pointed you towards the sticky topic where you should've posted this.

So, do yourself a favor, post it there so WG gets informed about this.

 

[Karasu_Browarszky]

12 minutes ago, 159Hunter said:

We're at page 3 and so far not a single forumite has pointed you towards the sticky topic where you should've posted this.

So, do yourself a favor, post it there so WG gets informed about this.

 

 

21 hours ago, Karasu_Browarszky said:

 

Sounds unfair to me too, not much you could have done to avoid it. You could try the pinned false positives thread.

 

4 hours ago, Karasu_Browarszky said:

@Wild_Butter Thanks for the replay, I recommend everyone watching the full.. one.. minute.. of your battle. I also definitely think this is a false positive, if you haven't posted it in the false positives thread do so, with the replay, and I think WG staff needs to have a look at it.

 

[Wild_Butter]

54 minutes ago, 159Hunter said:

We're at page 3 and so far not a single forumite has pointed you towards the sticky topic where you should've posted this.

So, do yourself a favor, post it there so WG gets informed about this.

evrything in this topic is hidden

[Karasu_Browarszky]

4 minutes ago, Wild_Butter said:

evrything in this topic is hidden

 

The pinned thread you mean? Yes, I guess you can see your own post, and only WG sees all of them.

[JohnMac79]

2 hours ago, KhorneFlake said:

Never said I m a unicum.

Doesnt change the fact Flamu isnt good either.

 

[SeaWolf7]

2 hours ago, KhorneFlake said:

 

You know, He is a crybaby and he's not even a good Player either.

 

2 hours ago, KhorneFlake said:

 

Doesn't change the fact Flamu isnt good either.

 

Dude...

The guy carries most of his games whilst deconstructing and explaining for the benefits of you and me. He also expose's wg shenanigan's in our favor.

Dont be bitter. Like him or not he's a hell of a lot better than you or me so you statement's are simply incorrect.

 

[Hugh_Ruka]

3 hours ago, KhorneFlake said:

Oh no...

Let me guess, he was ranting about the game afterwards for hours?

You know, He is a crybaby and he's not even a good Player either.

 

Don't watch his streams anymore, do something usefull like reading a book or finding a cure for cancer instead

It is funny ... I was watching a lot of other streamers but now I basically only watch Flamu regularly ... yes he rants a lot, but he's one of the best players I have seen on EU server.

[Karasu_Browarszky]

52 minutes ago, Hugh_Ruka said:

It is funny ... I was watching a lot of other streamers but now I basically only watch Flamu regularly ... yes he rants a lot, but he's one of the best players I have seen on EU server.

 

Very nicely trimmed beard too. I think Cap approves as well.

[VenividiviciNL]

5 hours ago, Karasu_Browarszky said:

 

 

Don't bother to post a reply on the mentioned WG thread as they do NOT reply at all.

 

I am still awaiting for a reply from them...............

[Karasu_Browarszky]

7 minutes ago, VenividiviciNL said:

Don't bother to post a reply on the mentioned WG thread as they do NOT reply at all.

 

I am still awaiting for a reply from them...............

 

All good things come to those who wait. ^{Firm nod}

[159Hunter]

18 hours ago, Karasu_Browarszky said:

 

 

My apologies, I missed your post (as there was no link )

17 hours ago, Wild_Butter said:

evrything in this topic is hidden

Yes, that's the point of that topic. 

13 hours ago, VenividiviciNL said:

Don't bother to post a reply on the mentioned WG thread as they do NOT reply at all.

 

I am still awaiting for a reply from them...............

So have you asked one of the forum mods for a status on what they did with your info?

@Seraphice might be good to comment on this one, before people consider your sticky topic useless.

[Karasu_Browarszky]

39 minutes ago, 159Hunter said:

My apologies, I missed your post (as there was no link )

 

 

You are right about the missing link. Thanks for posting it.

[VenividiviciNL]

2 hours ago, 159Hunter said:

So have you asked one of the forum mods for a status on what they did with your info?

@Seraphice might be good to comment on this one, before people consider your sticky topic useless.

I did sent a reply in that sticky WG post, without any clear answer so far....

 

That sticky post on "false positives" by WG was or a) a result of my post or b) anyhow following my OP at that time. I provided them with screenshots and replay, resulting into a non disclosure of what really happened.

 

As such I gave up on WG on this "false positives" and since the issue happened, I sail at 1/4 speed at a predetermined course to prevent such situation again (i.e. only 1 red ship left and your team in the lead for a few minutes remaining and my ship completely out of position or low on HP).

 

The flags which should lead to a correct positive distinction whether a player is non contributing to a battle are not working properly, besides being AFK (on purpose or by disconnection).

 

To my p.o.v. the OP in this thread is also hit by the wrong programming by WG as he unlucky died within the first minute, thanks to a CV. Maybe he should "get gud" before playing Randoms again, but the issue remains the same. 

 

Just my 2 pennies.

[Seraphice]

On 2/19/2023 at 8:06 PM, VenividiviciNL said:

Don't bother to post a reply on the mentioned WG thread as they do NOT reply at all.

 

I am still awaiting for a reply from them...............

as stated in that same thread: Please note that this is not a replacement for customer support, but rather an attempt to collect more data on the issue.

We are just collecting more data. Unfortunately, because people didn't actually reply to that thread all that much with replays of such incidents, it is very difficult for us to quantify this as a large issue - We reached out to try and gather this data and evidence to try to pin point where the issue is with the changes we made to the system, but the response on that thread was not in correlation to the magnitude of the problem that it is being made out to be.
For this, it really does help if you can provide us with replays of cases where this happens in that same thread.

 

 

[JohnMac79]

44 minutes ago, Seraphice said:

We are just collecting more data. Unfortunately, because people didn't actually reply to that thread all that much with replays of such incidents

Why were the thread replies hidden?

[159Hunter]

1 hour ago, JohnMac79 said:

Why were the thread replies hidden?

To hide the potential clusterf**** their rework of inactivity was.

 

If they were really keen on gathering data they would have informed all players in game, WG is well aware that only a small part of the population visits the forums.

[VenividiviciNL]

2 hours ago, Seraphice said:

as stated in that same thread: Please note that this is not a replacement for customer support, but rather an attempt to collect more data on the issue.

We are just collecting more data. Unfortunately, because people didn't actually reply to that thread all that much with replays of such incidents, it is very difficult for us to quantify this as a large issue - We reached out to try and gather this data and evidence to try to pin point where the issue is with the changes we made to the system, but the response on that thread was not in correlation to the magnitude of the problem that it is being made out to be.
For this, it really does help if you can provide us with replays of cases where this happens in that same thread.

 

 

Seraphice,

They were provided to CS and Yabbacoe (the latter received the ID as confirmation).

 

All I want(ed) to receive a detailed explanation on the false positive in my case, whereas my battleresults (including replay) provided more than sufficient information!

 

I gave up on WG on this issue as WG is not able to make a clear distinction how determine a positive (read Unsporting conduct by not participating at all), since the introduction of this (new) ruling. The first reaction by Yabbacoe to me on this problem was/is so ridiculous that I can't take him serious anymore.

 

WG created as usual a problem, which before was not in place. So many thanks for that (/off sarcasme).

 

Myself and many other players do like this game, but we are slowly loosing our fun, due to bad development/decisions made by WG.

 

You want my wallet reopened? Make good decisions instead of the crap WG is producing for the last 3 years!