[SERBS] RepSrb Players 653 posts 25,073 battles Report post #1 Posted January 24 When will we be able to donate from players account to clan treasury- steel ,coal ,or dobloons?? Also what happened to talk about players oil rewards earned n counted individually , and used for something? 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[EXIL] Wizard27_1979 WoWs Wiki Team, Supertester 2,558 posts 18,067 battles Report post #2 Posted January 24 18 minutes ago, RepSrb said: When will we be able to donate from players account to clan treasury- steel ,coal ,or dobloons?? Also what happened to talk about players oil rewards earned n counted individually , and used for something? I hope never, otherwise it'll be used to trade real money for those things (abuse). Don't remember any talk about giving oil another effect than "buffing" clan-base. 4 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[SERBS] RepSrb Players 653 posts 25,073 battles Report post #3 Posted January 24 Ok , so clan gives me 20.000 coal to get a ship, but i cant give it back to clan after some time.... fail. and by the way players can donate, just login on another players account for 1 time ,and buy dobloons for him anyway. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[PEZ] Yedwy Players 11,301 posts 39,586 battles Report post #4 Posted January 24 1 minute ago, RepSrb said: Ok , so clan gives me 20.000 coal to get a ship, but i cant give it back to clan after some time.... fail. Yep Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[TTT] floribe2000 [TTT] Moderator, WoWs Wiki Team, Freibeuter 2,714 posts 7,752 battles Report post #5 Posted January 24 Vor 58 Minuten, RepSrb sagte: Ok , so clan gives me 20.000 coal to get a ship, but i cant give it back to clan after some time.... fail. and by the way players can donate, just login on another players account for 1 time ,and buy dobloons for him anyway. The difference is that if you do that and something happens to your account because of that, WG will not help you because you violated the TOS. If they would allow donating resources to the clan treasury and someone abuses that (for example by hacking an account and then transfering all resources of that player) they would have to deal with that problem. In my opinion, the potential for abuse is far greater than the potential benefit this would bring. Also, the current concept of using the treasury to reward clan activity (like collecting resources through clan battles) encourages clan activity which is most likely what WG wants. 5 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[BLING] Cammo1962 [BLING] Players 2,468 posts 25,257 battles Report post #6 Posted January 24 13 minutes ago, floribe2000 said: The difference is that if you do that and something happens to your account because of that, WG will not help you because you violated the TOS. If they would allow donating resources to the clan treasury and someone abuses that (for example by hacking an account and then transfering all resources of that player) they would have to deal with that problem. In my opinion, the potential for abuse is far greater than the potential benefit this would bring. Also, the current concept of using the treasury to reward clan activity (like collecting resources through clan battles) encourages clan activity which is most likely what WG wants. As fare as I remember when the clan treasury came out we were supposed to be able to donate coal and steel to it but it never happened @floribe2000 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[PUPSI] Klopirat Freibeuter 15,160 posts Report post #7 Posted January 24 Vor 1 Stunde, RepSrb sagte: and by the way players can donate, just login on another players account for 1 time ,and buy dobloons for him anyway. but in this case you don't transfer ingame items but buy stuff 'directly' in the premium shop with real money (and of course you don't need to login to someones account to gift him ships/doubloons)... 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[BLING] Cammo1962 [BLING] Players 2,468 posts 25,257 battles Report post #8 Posted January 24 1 hour ago, RepSrb said: Ok , so clan gives me 20.000 coal to get a ship, but i cant give it back to clan after some time.... fail. and by the way players can donate, just login on another players account for 1 time ,and buy dobloons for him anyway. It is not possible to donate anything to the clan treasury and I have tried it in our clan but no dice. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[PUPSI] Klopirat Freibeuter 15,160 posts Report post #9 Posted January 24 Vor 6 Minuten, Cammo1962 sagte: As fare as I remember when the clan treasury came out we were supposed to be able to donate coal and steel to it but it never happened @floribe2000 at least in the patch notes this was not mentioned as far as I can see Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[BLING] Cammo1962 [BLING] Players 2,468 posts 25,257 battles Report post #10 Posted January 24 4 minutes ago, Klopirat said: at least in the patch notes this was not mentioned as far as I can see Thats why i said as fare as i remembered and i think they said it on one of their streams when people asked about it and again I am not 100% sure. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[PEZ] Yedwy Players 11,301 posts 39,586 battles Report post #11 Posted January 24 2 hours ago, floribe2000 said: the current concept of using the treasury to reward clan activity (like collecting resources through clan battles) encourages clan activity which is most likely what WG wants. Soo which regular activity a clan can undergo gives steel or doubloons? Thats right - none... Barr the occaisonal KOTS or similar sponsored event there is no way to earn them for clan treasury and WG DID promise the donating feature is in the pipeline but it somehow faded away together with great many other things when the glorious sub rework got started... 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[SERBS] RepSrb Players 653 posts 25,073 battles Report post #12 Posted January 24 i am old enough in this game to know there was talk about 2 way transactions with clan treasury-clan members , individual oil which was supposed to be used for purchases, etc.... plenty of empty promises 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[NOWH] Tordenskjold23 Players 431 posts 37,565 battles Report post #13 Posted January 24 5 hours ago, Cammo1962 said: As fare as I remember when the clan treasury came out we were supposed to be able to donate coal and steel to it but it never happened It did - take a look pn this from NOWH page Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[FDOW] VenividiviciNL Players 595 posts 35,389 battles Report post #14 Posted January 24 2 hours ago, Tordenskjold23 said: It did - take a look pn this from NOWH page Old man, you are referring to Clan treasury donations to individual members (receiving end), but the OP is about individual members donating access resources to Clan treasury (receiving end) for occasional distribution to other clanmembers. Whether this is good or not in case of implementation, time will tell. By the looks of your picture your staff members are on the receiving end of the clan rewards, how pathetic! You only got the leftovers......... 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[SFSO] Ymustihaveaname Players 362 posts 14,119 battles Report post #15 Posted January 25 18 hours ago, Yedwy said: Soo which regular activity a clan can undergo gives steel Does Clan battles not give steel for higher levels, ie Typhoon, 2 or top 50 teams? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
[WG] Seraphice WG Staff 1,664 posts 7,808 battles Report post #16 Posted January 25 17 hours ago, RepSrb said: i am old enough in this game to know there was talk about 2 way transactions with clan treasury-clan members , individual oil which was supposed to be used for purchases, etc.... plenty of empty promises Hello! If you can link me to where we made these promises I can follow up on them internally, but for now the arguments brought by @Wizard27_1979 and @floribe2000 are more than enough reason not to implement this currently. Fair seas captain! ~Sera Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
