Not a defence of planes thread.

[Corpsetaker]

Hello,

 

Just want to say this is not a defence of CV's and planes in any way but an overall criticism of the mechanics. I'm the kind of person who believes if you are going to have something in a game like this try and make your mechanics consistent and at least make some sense. I'm not asking for realism or anything but just to have some consistency. I was watching my mate play his CV last night and I just noticed something about the planes and their interactions with ships and I noticed how much a battleship and heavy cruiser can out manoeuvre an airplane. Let's take a battleship moving at 30 Knots and an airplane moving at 140 knots. That battleship should not be able to out turn an airplane but alas it can. I'm not sure if this is done on purpose because it could make CV's even more OP than they already are but I suspect it's just bad design. I would rather they just remove CV's and planes all together but I don't see that happening. I just like for things to make as much sense as possible and to me it just doesn't.

[Yosha_AtaIante]

Its for balancing reasons. Otherwise CVs would be to strong

[Panocek]

[________________Morrison]

No defense but. I'm getting dejavu.

 

 

[Mad_Dog_Dante]

50 minutes ago, Corpsetaker said:

Hello,

 

bad design

 

[Wulf_Ace]

its arcade game

[Mr_Damager]

a BB can avoid torpedo bombers' attack by turning around

[_Lupastro_]

3 ore fa, Corpsetaker ha scritto:

Hello,

 

Just want to say this is not a defence of CV's and planes in any way but an overall criticism of the mechanics. I'm the kind of person who believes if you are going to have something in a game like this try and make your mechanics consistent and at least make some sense. I'm not asking for realism or anything but just to have some consistency. I was watching my mate play his CV last night and I just noticed something about the planes and their interactions with ships and I noticed how much a battleship and heavy cruiser can out manoeuvre an airplane. Let's take a battleship moving at 30 Knots and an airplane moving at 140 knots. That battleship should not be able to out turn an airplane but alas it can. I'm not sure if this is done on purpose because it could make CV's even more OP than they already are but I suspect it's just bad design. I would rather they just remove CV's and planes all together but I don't see that happening. I just like for things to make as much sense as possible and to me it just doesn't.

The beginning seems to be that of a thread in defense of CVs. Its evolution ends in the extinction of the CVs themselves (which I would like)...

Interesting Darwinian theory on the evolution of the CV virus, I love this post that starts salty to end sweet and with clear and confused ideas together.