WoWs clans shared or not shared with WoT

[Konami77]

 

Hi guys,

I'm a WoT player of long time I have just discovered - after sending a ticket to the support - that clans inside WoT will be shared in WoWs, or better, all our accounts share clans in all Wargaming games, World of Warplanes included.

 

This decision, in my opinion, could be a big problem for players that are interested to play WoWs and WoT too, because if they wants enter in (or found) a new clan in WoWs, automatically they'll lose the WoT clan and the new WoWs clan become the new clan in WoT.

 

I known that this problem could be solved creating a second account, but why I should be forced to create a second account (that is prohibited by WG policy) in order to solve this problem ?

My suggestion is keep separated clans in all Wargaming games, in order that players should not be forced to abandon a game for another or create multiple accounts to solve this problem.

 

If Wargaming decide to proceed in this way, and supposing to have a single account per user, I see this problem: not all players are interested to play WoT and WoWs too, so if I like my WoT clan and I want not abadon it I'll be unable to play WoWs because all players are focused on WoT. So only solution is stop playing WoT in order to play WoWs (and vice versa).

 

Please tell me what you think about this and I'm sorry for my bad english. 

 

Regards,

Paolo

 

[Orlunu]

Or recruit some people into your clan who play WoWS.

[krautjaeger]

I reckon the first time you enter WoWs they may give you a pop-up if you want to remain in your current clan combined with a 30-60 second non-cancelable countdown so people don't press 'No' without reading just to get in the game.

[Konami77]

Orlunu: recruiting players for WoWs will "sacrifice" players for WoT clan wars so it's a problem not easy to be managed.

krautjaeger: hehe, onestly I have not payed too much attention to this disclaimer, but when clans will be ready in WoWs problem will pop out if someone is playing WoT too in a clan that play clan wars.

[daki]

 

It would definitely be a terrible idea if they "force" players in common clans for WoT & WoWs.

As it was already discussed elsewhere, an active clan in WoT may or may not be sufficiently active in WoWs (to the liking of a particular player).

Not to mention players which may want to be part of a clan in one game and not both.

I think that the best solution would be to have completely independent clans between the games, and that the recruiting in WoWs is done from scratch.

Technically speaking it is rather just a matter of a field in the profiles database and will not in any way affect the unified account approach.

 

[Orlunu]

Orlunu: recruiting players for WoWs will "sacrifice" players for WoT clan wars so it's a problem not easy to be managed.

Getting a single decent clan wars tank isn't exactly strenuous, especially if you're the kind of person who'll be going to that type of competitive clan, and, likewise, there will be many dedicated WoT players who dabble with WoWS.  Sure, it won't be highly competitive in both at the same time, but, then again, neither will the individual, so he can pick which leaning suits him.

 

Not to mention players which may want to be part of a clan in one game and not both.

What?  It's not hard to ignore the clan chat panel.

 

 

I agree that it'd be better to have separate clans, but it's no disaster if they're unified (which they will be).

[Pekoe_Darjeeling]

Unified acc is great when it comes to sharing  gold free xp one login but 2 things - nickname and clan could be separate so you don't have to leave wot clan in order to join your friends who play wows or if you want to change nickname only for one game.

[Konami77]

Getting a single decent clan wars tank isn't exactly strenuous, especially if you're the kind of person who'll be going to that type of competitive clan, and, likewise, there will be many dedicated WoT players who dabble with WoWS.  Sure, it won't be highly competitive in both at the same time, but, then again, neither will the individual, so he can pick which leaning suits him.

 

 

Yes, you are true, we cannot be competitive in both games but if wants to be competitive in one game only, like WoWs, I'll be forced to leave my WoT clan that actually is my the clan of my friends where I'll play mainly for fun. Keep separated clans will solve any problems. 

[Orlunu]

Yes, you are true, we cannot be competitive in both games but if wants to be competitive in one game only, like WoWs, I'll be forced to leave my WoT clan that actually is my the clan of my friends where I'll play mainly for fun.

 

Does that matter?  Maybe my clan has a particularly odd setup, but most of our "clanmates" who we always talk to on our forum, on TS and in game, as well as who we play with in game, aren't technically in the clan.  We actually get moments when we're trying to arrange strongholds and suchlike when we pick someone just for them to surprise us by reminding us that they aren't technically in the clan.

 

So, to my mind, formal enrollment only really matters for competitive play, although I do agree with you that things would be a little simpler if they kept them separate.

[Hanszeehock]

Unified clans were a big problem for WoWP/WoT players. Given the WoWS population will be much larger if they bring unified clans here as well there will be a lot of unhappiness. I think the last thing I read was that it had not been decided yet. I really hope they will find a way to implement completely separate clans for WoWS. 

[TopDawg]

Also a clan name in wot may not be suitable for wows .....

[Orlunu]

Unified clans were a big problem for WoWP/WoT players.

 

There are WoWP players? 

 

Plz no kill, mods...

[OldGrandad]

No to unification, period. Three entirely different games with few that like all. Nothing wrong in having a'mother' clan and have 3 different sibling clans for the three different games.

[Orlunu]

Nothing wrong in having a'mother' clan and have 3 different sibling clans for the three different games.

 

Even that pretty much only works by allowing more people in, but enforcing variety.  May be a workable solution, but completely separate clans sounds like a better idea.

[Konami77]

Ok guys, we are all agree that keep separated clans in every game is better, from one reason of from another.

I hope that this topic could have a lot of reply from many other users in order to encourage Wargaming to consider this issue.

 

Thanks all

[Mercury67]

Hi guys,
I'm a WoT player of long time I have just discovered - after sending a ticket to the support - that clans inside WoT will be shared in WoWs, or better, all our accounts share clans in all Wargaming games, World of Warplanes included.

 

This decision, in my opinion, could be a big problem for players that are interested to play WoWs and WoT too, because if they wants enter in (or found) a new clan in WoWs, automatically they'll lose the WoT clan and the new WoWs clan become the new clan in WoT.

 

I known that this problem could be solved creating a second account, but why I should be forced to create a second account (that is prohibited by WG policy) in order to solve this problem ?

My suggestion is keep separated clans in all Wargaming games, in order that players should not be forced to abandon a game for another or create multiple accounts to solve this problem.

 

If Wargaming decide to proceed in this way, and supposing to have a single account per user, I see this problem: not all players are interested to play WoT and WoWs too, so if I like my WoT clan and I want not abadon it I'll be unable to play WoWs because all players are focused on WoT. So only solution is stop playing WoT in order to play WoWs (and vice versa).

 

Please tell me what you think about this and I'm sorry for my bad english. 

 

Regards,
Paolo

 

[Mercury67]

I agree with Konami77. Keep separated games and Clans.

 

Best regards

 

Massimo

 

[23gale]

 

I think that the best solution would be to have completely independent clans between the games, and that the recruiting in WoWs is done from scratch.

I also agree, is much more useful and intelligent to have the clan separated from the various games wargaming.

Sorry for my bad english. 

[NavigatorX]

I think Konami is absolutely right, as i think too, that WG never will agree to this statement because i suppose they are looking for new players and don't agree so much to gain player in WOWS as transfered from WOT: so they will tend to make less easier to pass, at less for clan, from a game to another.

 

[X1376]

don't agree so much to gain player in WOWS as transfered from WOT: so they will tend to make less easier to pass, at less for clan, from a game to another.

 

I do not see the point. Unified account makes your premium time and gold shared anyway, so it does not matter if you play one or two game, WG will profit on you so or so.

 

But having unified account as user with premium and gold while having option for different clans per game would be great solution.

 

Finally that would mean even more socializing and more ties within the game at the end. And WG knows, that what makes you stick longer is socialization...

[Konami77]

But having unified account as user with premium and gold while having option for different clans per game would be great solution.

 

 

totally agree with you X1376, there is no reason (imo) to separe account in different games. Point is only on separate clans in different games.

bye!

[Kuscka]

Well I think we separate the two clans.  WoTs and Wows we have two clan forums for our clan and its working.. After all you totally going to have to keep them separate how else would you manage everyone?

[Tsunami15]

Hello,

I'm agree to separate clans for every "world of" games, good idea to avoid problem of multiple accounts and let free players to join different clans in different games.

Otherwise, let players enter in more than one clan (why not ? )

Bye!

[dapprman]

I like the idea of keeping the clans together, but then they'd need to increase the membership limit as 100 players between 3 games would be just too few.

 

However I only said I liked the idea, not that I'm sold on it.  My Clan/Guild/Fleet came out of the Navyfield Europe servers and many of us would love to play together again, however those of us in WoT are now spread across multiple clans as we never took the latter as seriously as NFEU and became more of a gaming guild.  Our more serious members went else where, but want to go naval with us all again like in the old days.

 

Net result, can't make up my mind

[X1376]

@dapprman: If you had option to have separate clans in every game, nothing would prevent you being in the same clan in every game at the end. It is still more flexible for clan member...