Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
You need to play a total of 50 battles to post in this section.
who_dares_wins

The Tier V Elimination Thread 2: Electric Boogaloo

6 comments in this topic

Recommended Posts

Players
237 posts
1,740 battles

Rather than resurrect a two year old thread, I'm going to start an "elimination thread" for the tier V ranked season, taking into account all the new ships that have been added since then (i.e. Since my hiatus). If you don't know who I am or what such a thread is or was, fear not, I shall explain. I'm nobody important, and an elimination thread works as follows:

Every ship in a category is added to a list, and begins with a value of 20. Each poster posts the list, adding one to a ship that they think is competitive and taking three from one they think is not competitive, stating their reasoning. When a ship reaches a value of zero, it is eliminated. The last ship remaining "wins". There are a few rules:

 

1: The context of the ranked sprint must be taken into account

2: You must have played a ship to vote it up or down.

3: You may only post once a day

4: You may not change the point totals in any way except those defined.

 

The current list:

Minekaze: 14 

Mutsuki: 20

Kamikaze (R): 21

Furutaka: 21 

Kongo: 20

Zuiho: 20

Nicholas: 20

Omaha: 17

Marblehead (Lima): 20

New York: 17 

Texas: 20

Bogue: 20

Podvoisky: 20

Okhotnik: 20

Gremyashchy: 21 

Kirov: 20

Krazny Krym: 20

Murmansk: 20

Okt. Revolution: 20

T-22: 17

Konigsberg: 21

Konig: 20

Acasta: 20

Emerald: 20

Iron Duke: 20

Emile Bertin: 20

Bretagne: 20

Jianwei: 20

Giulio Cesare: 21

 

Let it begin!

Edited by who_dares_wins
Updating scoreboard

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quality Poster
2,946 posts
7,933 battles

Minekaze: 20

Mutsuki: 20

Kamikaze (R): 20

Furutaka: 20

Kongo: 20

Zuiho: 20

Nicholas: 20

Omaha: 20 

Marblehead (Lima): 20

New York: 20

Texas: 20

Bogue: 20

Podvoisky: 20

Okhotnik: 20

Gremyashchy: 20

Kirov: 20

Krazny Krym: 20

Murmansk: 20

Okt. Revolution: 20

T-22: 17 (-3) Who want's to play a fish trawler with low DPM and horrible concealment?

Konigsberg: 20

Konig: 20

Acasta: 20

Emerald: 20

Iron Duke: 20

Emile Bertin: 20

Bretagne: 20

Jianwei: 20

Giulio Cesare: 21 (+1) OP ship ... do I need to say more?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
[B0TS]
Beta Tester
1,556 posts
4,764 battles

Minekaze: 17 (-3 due to much better choices available

Mutsuki: 20

Kamikaze (R): 21 (+1 due to probably the most op t5 DD - I have Fujin, which is a reskin of this.

Furutaka: 20

Kongo: 20

Zuiho: 20

Nicholas: 20

Omaha: 20 

Marblehead (Lima): 20

New York: 20

Texas: 20

Bogue: 20

Podvoisky: 20

Okhotnik: 20

Gremyashchy: 20

Kirov: 20

Krazny Krym: 20

Murmansk: 20

Okt. Revolution: 20

T-22: 17

Konigsberg: 20

Konig: 20

Acasta: 20

Emerald: 20

Iron Duke: 20

Emile Bertin: 20

Bretagne: 20

Jianwei: 20

Giulio Cesare: 21

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Players
3,449 posts
7,226 battles

Minekaze: 17 14 (all IJN DD are bad choice for ranked)

Mutsuki: 20

Kamikaze (R): 21

Furutaka: 20

Kongo: 20

Zuiho: 20

Nicholas: 20

Omaha: 20 

Marblehead (Lima): 20

New York: 20

Texas: 20

Bogue: 20

Podvoisky: 20

Okhotnik: 20

Gremyashchy: 20 21 (OP at T6)

Kirov: 20

Krazny Krym: 20

Murmansk: 20

Okt. Revolution: 20

T-22: 17

Konigsberg: 20

Konig: 20

Acasta: 20

Emerald: 20

Iron Duke: 20

Emile Bertin: 20

Bretagne: 20

Jianwei: 20

Giulio Cesare: 21

 

@who_dares_wins can I suggest that to speed things up we split this into classes and have one vote per day for each class, thus the above becomes:

 

Spoiler

DD

Spoiler

Minekaze: 14

Mutsuki: 20

Kamikaze (R): 21

Nicholas: 20

Podvoisky: 20

Okhotnik: 20

Gremyashchy: 21

T-22: 17

Acasta: 20

Jianwei: 20

 

 

CA/CL

Spoiler
Furutaka: 20 21 (203 mm at T5, oh yes!)

Omaha: 20 

Marblehead (Lima): 20

Kirov: 20

Krazny Krym: 20

Murmansk: 20

Konigsberg: 20

Emerald: 20 17 (one of the worst ships in the game)

Emile Bertin: 20

BB

Spoiler
Kongo: 20

New York: 20 17 (powercrept)

Texas: 20

Okt. Revolution: 20

Konig: 20

Iron Duke: 20 21 (because HE citadel hits against all T5 cruisers is balance comrade)

Bretagne: 20

Giulio Cesare: 21

 

CV

Spoiler
Zuiho: 20

Bogue: 20

 

No comment.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Players
75 posts
2,445 battles

Minekaze: 14 

Mutsuki: 20

Kamikaze (R): 21

Furutaka: 20

Kongo: 20

Zuiho: 20

Nicholas: 20

Omaha: 20 17 (far too much citadel, while it is great in even games it has no ability to solo carry against 2-3 ships which a lot of T5 ranked games will come down to)

Marblehead (Lima): 20

New York: 20

Texas: 20

Bogue: 20

Podvoisky: 20

Okhotnik: 20

Gremyashchy: 21 

Kirov: 20

Krazny Krym: 20

Murmansk: 20

Okt. Revolution: 20

T-22: 17

Konigsberg: 20 21 (did someone say kite all day long with its A XY turret configuration?)

Konig: 20

Acasta: 20

Emerald: 20

Iron Duke: 20

Emile Bertin: 20

Bretagne: 20

Jianwei: 20

Giulio Cesare: 21

 

(These values include changes made by Capra76 above)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
[TTT]
Players
3,568 posts
7,449 battles

Minekaze: 14 

Mutsuki: 20

Kamikaze (R): 21

Furutaka: 20 + 1 = 21 (because 8 inch guns at this tier are hilarious)

Kongo: 20

Zuiho: 20

Nicholas: 20

Omaha: 17

Marblehead (Lima): 20

New York: 20 - 3 = 17 (there's just nothing even remotely decent about this hulk of flotsam)

Texas: 20

Bogue: 20

Podvoisky: 20

Okhotnik: 20

Gremyashchy: 21 

Kirov: 20

Krazny Krym: 20

Murmansk: 20

Okt. Revolution: 20

T-22: 17

Konigsberg: 21

Konig: 20

Acasta: 20

Emerald: 20

Iron Duke: 20

Emile Bertin: 20

Bretagne: 20

Jianwei: 20

Giulio Cesare: 21

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×