Jump to content
You need to play a total of 50 battles to post in this section.
Pagster123

Italian BB Sneak Peak

5 comments in this topic

Recommended Posts

Players
55 posts
2,249 battles

This post will be coming around either tomorrow or the day after. I'm going to go into detail about each of these ships.

NOTE: Caio Duilio is a suggested Tier VI BB premium which I will talk about eventually.
 

Tier III: Pisa

file.thumb.png.4685fd03ae74ace4064074052250978c.png

 

Tier IV: Dante Alighieri

dante_alighiery_battleship_by_acelanceloet.thumb.png.5aa5dbc736ec646c2c25daf9a9a5ccb7.png
 
Tier V: Conti di Cavour
5b009daba28f2_file(1).thumb.png.241d16d4d010cae991d3e39c8ab80c7e.png
 
 
Tier VI: Andrea Doria
5b009de59522b_file(2).thumb.png.4371a390cb977908c19af1d9c24632db.png
 
Tier VII: Sicily (placeholder name until I think of a better one, this is the ONLY image I could find of this elusive design):42507a4ebd270122afc72f82899e790f.thumb.jpg.68d53fec9b49eacec5c4cba9d748d778.jpg
 
Tier VIII: Littorio
5b009e327051c_file(3).thumb.png.952238ca80485fb255f8cf461b1c3021.png
 
 
Tier IX: Livorno
5b009e5440f5b_file(4).thumb.png.284eb7b89bc4fa3906d6dbb78919257d.png
 
Tier X: Sardegna (placeholder name until I think of a better one)
5b009ea94aed5_file(5).thumb.png.877f152dd1c9a4b4afa31f417440b7fa.png
FYI: This thing would have 18 inch guns. Or else it would be crap at tier X.
 
Let me know if you like the names "Sicily" and "Sardegna" respectively or suggest new ones! And of course, tell me your suggestions. I'll be shortly following this up with a post going through each of these in quite some detail.
Happy sailing!

regua.png

  • Cool 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Beta Tester
5,108 posts
2,939 battles

1\ Could you add the design name of the TVII ? Since you used a placeholder name, I don't know what design you're referring to.

 

2\ Livorno (the 1928 23kt CC) has not a chance of making it at tier IX. And not even at TVIII. Not sure what you're thinking putting it above Littorio. I mean, it's slower, has less armor, only has six guns, is much less heavy and thus has less hitpoints, has less AA power - I even wonder if it'd belong at TVII or not. It's even arguably not belonging any higher than TVI.

 

3\ UP41 wouldn't fit at TX indeed. But it fits TIX perfectly well. Also you can't randomely slap 457mm on it cause you want. That's not how it works. If you wanna make a 457mm-wielding TX, work around Cassone's project, but don't just alter the caliber of a planned design without a basis.

 

4\ Not sure what Pisa you're referring to but if it's the one I know, it's an armored cruiser. Not even a battleship. Doesn't belong in such a line at all.

 

5\ Why use Cavour and Doria's rebuilt version both at TV and TVI ? You could use the original of one at TV and the rebuilt of the other at TVI.

 

 

  • Cool 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Players
55 posts
2,249 battles
11 hours ago, LastButterfly said:

1\ Could you add the design name of the TVII ? Since you used a placeholder name, I don't know what design you're referring to.

 

2\ Livorno (the 1928 23kt CC) has not a chance of making it at tier IX. And not even at TVIII. Not sure what you're thinking putting it above Littorio. I mean, it's slower, has less armor, only has six guns, is much less heavy and thus has less hitpoints, has less AA power - I even wonder if it'd belong at TVII or not. It's even arguably not belonging any higher than TVI.

 

3\ UP41 wouldn't fit at TX indeed. But it fits TIX perfectly well. Also you can't randomely slap 457mm on it cause you want. That's not how it works. If you wanna make a 457mm-wielding TX, work around Cassone's project, but don't just alter the caliber of a planned design without a basis.

 

4\ Not sure what Pisa you're referring to but if it's the one I know, it's an armored cruiser. Not even a battleship. Doesn't belong in such a line at all.

 

5\ Why use Cavour and Doria's rebuilt version both at TV and TVI ? You could use the original of one at TV and the rebuilt of the other at TVI.

 

 

Thank you for the criticism. I will take this into account.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Players
41 posts
1,828 battles
On ‎2018‎-‎05‎-‎20 at 12:03 AM, Pagster123 said:

This post will be coming around either tomorrow or the day after. I'm going to go into detail about each of these ships.

NOTE: Caio Duilio is a suggested Tier VI BB premium which I will talk about eventually.
 

Tier III: Pisa

file.thumb.png.4685fd03ae74ace4064074052250978c.png

 

Tier IV: Dante Alighieri

dante_alighiery_battleship_by_acelanceloet.thumb.png.5aa5dbc736ec646c2c25daf9a9a5ccb7.png
 
Tier V: Conti di Cavour
5b009daba28f2_file(1).thumb.png.241d16d4d010cae991d3e39c8ab80c7e.png
 
 
Tier VI: Andrea Doria
5b009de59522b_file(2).thumb.png.4371a390cb977908c19af1d9c24632db.png
 
Tier VII: Sicily (placeholder name until I think of a better one, this is the ONLY image I could find of this elusive design):42507a4ebd270122afc72f82899e790f.thumb.jpg.68d53fec9b49eacec5c4cba9d748d778.jpg
 
Tier VIII: Littorio
5b009e327051c_file(3).thumb.png.952238ca80485fb255f8cf461b1c3021.png
 
 
Tier IX: Livorno
5b009e5440f5b_file(4).thumb.png.284eb7b89bc4fa3906d6dbb78919257d.png
 
Tier X: Sardegna (placeholder name until I think of a better one)
5b009ea94aed5_file(5).thumb.png.877f152dd1c9a4b4afa31f417440b7fa.png
FYI: This thing would have 18 inch guns. Or else it would be crap at tier X.
 
Let me know if you like the names "Sicily" and "Sardegna" respectively or suggest new ones! And of course, tell me your suggestions. I'll be shortly following this up with a post going through each of these in quite some detail.
Happy sailing!

regua.png

 

Good Work  Pagster 123. Keep Going. Thank You.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
[ITA_5]
Players
262 posts
6,075 battles
Alle 20/5/2018 alle 00:03, Pagster123 ha scritto:

This post will be coming around either tomorrow or the day after. I'm going to go into detail about each of these ships.

NOTE: Caio Duilio is a suggested Tier VI BB premium which I will talk about eventually.
 

Tier III: Pisa

Tier IV: Dante Alighieri

Tier V: Conti di Cavour

Tier VI: Andrea Doria

Tier VII: Sicily (placeholder name until I think of a better one, this is the ONLY image I could find of this elusive design)

Tier VIII: Littorio

Tier IX: Livorno

Tier X: Sardegna (placeholder name until I think of a better one)

FYI: This thing would have 18 inch guns. Or else it would be crap at tier X.

Let me know if you like the names "Sicily" and "Sardegna" respectively or suggest new ones! And of course, tell me your suggestions. I'll be shortly following this up with a post going through each of these in quite some detail.

Happy sailing!

regua.png

GOOD! Can you do something like that also for DD and CL/CA?

  • Cool 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×