from perspective of CV:
1) the game play gets dull very fast, reason - there is no risk involved.( infinite planes )
2) there is no interaction with enemy CV, the only competition is who makes more damage in shortest amount of time
3) match outcome still or even more depends on which team has best CV
4) killing DDs in smoke now is easier than ever ( I bet it's fun and engaging for DD)
from perspective of surface ship:
1)AA is inconsistent and mostly useless.
2)DAA see point (1)
3)the catapult fighter "squad" is just silly.
4)it does not metter how many planes i shoot down there is always new squad 20sec away.
5)the new mechanics of AA side reinforcement just useless.
6)over all I feel powerless against CV even on american cruiser