Jump to content
Forum Shutdown 28/7/2023 Read more... ×

Culiacan_Mexico

Players
 View profile  See their activity

  • Content Сount

    2,844

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Battles

    14993

Everything posted by Culiacan_Mexico

  1. Culiacan_Mexico
    Why would a "DD player" care is a BB got def AA? Someone who cared about game balance might. Just to add on... you know hypocrisy and all. A Fletcher clone with these torpedoes gives CA/CL about 4.5 sec reaction time, which is great for me as a DD player, but is it justified game balance wise? I don't see it. Hopefully testing will clarify. Now your turn. Come out against cruiser tools being installed on BBs. ----------------------------- 533mm Mk.16 mod.1 DW (2 x 5)Damage: 24400Speed: 66 knotsReload: 106sRange: 10.5 kmDetectability: 0.8 kmTorpedo Depth: 6 m
  2. Culiacan_Mexico
    ----Chungmu-Ex-USS Erben, Fletcher-class destroyer, in ROK Navy service--- Fletcher guns with anti-cruiser torpedoes. That should get interesting.
  3. Culiacan_Mexico
    Probably not. Mediocre BB players already are in snipe mode; and while decent players BB may not like the added risk of DW torpedoes, they know that snipe mode is fairly ineffective. DW torpedoes don't give extended range, just for the most part, reduced reaction time; and as is, the majority of BBs at mid tiers have no interest in getting into torpedo range... excluding the Germans, but they have hydro, Tier 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Torpedo Range 6.0 km 6.0 km 5.5 km 6.0 km 8.0 km 8.0 km 9.15 km 10.5 km 13.5 km
  4. Culiacan_Mexico
    Would it be fair to say that DDs make up less than 25% of ships played on average? Is this where you would like them to be? Note: I play DDs, so less DDs the better for me. All battle tiers, Random battle DDs and CV = 26.5 % Battle tier X, Random battle DDs and CV = 28.9% Battle tier VIII, Random battle DDs and CV = 24.5%
  5. Culiacan_Mexico
    Good question.
  6. Culiacan_Mexico
    I play DDs. This is at worst a minor buff to my game play, because even if I don't use DW torpedoes if my opponents do... I am immune. For me it isn't about losing vs gaining something... that is fine, but that it just looks like cruisers are going to suffer the most from these new torpedoes. I could be wrong, so I would be interested in see what testing shows.
  7. Culiacan_Mexico
    If your opponent smokes up, you will.
  8. Culiacan_Mexico
    Maybe. I will have to wait until the come out, but I don't believe they will be releases 'as is'.
  9. Culiacan_Mexico
    Will it? As is stated now, DD players must choose before the game starts: choose normal torpedoes and nothing is very different, but if you choose the new torpedoes cruiser will suffer but your ability to counter other DDs is nerfed. More BBs will just sit in the back and be relatively unaffected.
  10. Culiacan_Mexico
    Cruisers?
  11. Culiacan_Mexico
    I could be doing it wrong, but.. it looks like at some tiers cruiser will have there reaction time reduced to about 4.5 seconds. Because a lot of cruiser players are on or near the front, there will be no one to spot the torpedoes a head of time. That seems a bit rough. Drange / (Vtorp * .0026) = Treaction
  12. Culiacan_Mexico
    The answer is obvious: allow DDs to select torpedo type in game, while making cruiser immune to the new torpedoes.
  13. Culiacan_Mexico
    Tier VI Tier VII Tier VIII Tier IX Tier X Torpedo Detection Range 1.2 km 1.3 km 1.1 km 1.4 km 1.4 km "Deep Water" Detection Range 0.8 km 0.8 km 0.7 km 0.8 km 0.8 km If they do hit cruisers, reaction time is reduce by about 1/3, which is a significant nerf. I can't see how that is justified. This isn't a Battleships nerf, but a cruiser one.
  14. Culiacan_Mexico
    They can now sit in the back with those BB players that like to camp.
  15. Culiacan_Mexico
    If the new torpedoes are effective against CA/CLs, it will make their survival more difficult; but if the new torpedoes are ineffective against CA/CL it will leave DDs no effective weapons system against them. Either a DD or a CA/CL nerf.
  16. Culiacan_Mexico
    It sure is looking that way.
  17. Culiacan_Mexico
    "Similar to Enterprise's dive bombers, Pan Asian DDs can only carry either regular torpedo or deep water torpedo into battle."
  18. Culiacan_Mexico
    I can't see many DDs where this choice would be viable. Perhaps the Fletcher if they are effective against Cruisers.
  19. Culiacan_Mexico
    What about CVs?
  20. Culiacan_Mexico
    It is a thought.
  21. Culiacan_Mexico
    Maybe, but if it works... isn't it countering the type of BB play that we wish? Up close fighters? Campers will be virtually unaffected. I am interested in seeing what they are planning.
  22. Culiacan_Mexico
    You are correct.
  23. Culiacan_Mexico

    Bored this crying noobs.

    Culiacan_Mexico replied to KHS01's topic in General Discussion

    Kid. Thank you
  24. Culiacan_Mexico

    Perth, Albert & Duca are back! But not for doubloons? :(

    Culiacan_Mexico replied to zaaaaaaP's topic in General Discussion

    BBs always seem to out last CA/CLs.
  25. Culiacan_Mexico

    campbeltown buff needed

    Culiacan_Mexico replied to matalanfighter's topic in General Discussion

    I haven't played any DDs at that level for sometime, but my problem was... My stats Ship Games Played WR Damage Derzki 251 61.35% 29,718 (Torpedoes 5 х 2 is silly fun) Wickes 207 63.29% 31,310 (Great torpedo knife fighter) Wakatake 159 68.55% 47,215 (Long range stealth killer) Campbeltown 34 61.76% 30,787 (Something... I just never got a feel for it.) Maybe I should have just given it time.
×