ColonelPete

Then you would prove it, instead of just claiming it.

This did not happen here.

When you do not read what I write, but read what you imagine, this can happen.

Du verstehen?

Ich habe nicht gesagt das man sie nicht so spielen kann. Du kannst auch eine Tirpitz als Torpedoboot fahren. Ich habe gesagt das dies keine gute Idee ist. Ja, der eine oder andere schafft gute Gefechte damit, aber das dürfte doch wohl eher ungewöhnlich sein. Was wir in Video sehen: Clan Gefechte 1 DD im Gegnerteam ein Radar mit begrenzter Reichweite und leicht zu spotten Und jetzt vergleich das mal mit den Radom Gefechten.

Sounds like a BB player...

Ragnar looks interesting, but I would prever a version without radar, but with smoke. Repulse is a next step towards implementation of BC into the game. Class and Tier are ok. The plating is a bit questionable, I hope that will not be the bow plating. Even Kongo has 19mm as a BC on Tier V. Repulse gives up firepower (1 turret less) and belt armor for her speed. Removing the ability to tank when angled would make her inferior to a BB her Tier.

8km torps mittelmässiges Concealment Kanonen mit denen man sich nicht mehr verteidigen kann Auf Tier X ist das keine gute Idee.

Radar on DD - meh 152mm guns on DD - ok, that could be interesting.

Es ist Mist. Du kannst aus der Kleber kein Torpedoboot machen.

When the enemy camps at max range, I do not need to push. I just take out the the cruisers and DD around the caps and my team wins. that is not 1v1 Lesson about ship fires. there is enough flamable stuff on deck (planes, wooden boats, emergency rafts, guns, hydraulic oil for the guns, ready ammunition for guns, Iowa had handgranades stored outside the bridge in metal lockers) HE goes through the thinner parts of the armor and start fires on the inside (chairs, clothing, people, food,...) fires get hot, the heat goes through armor and ignites stuff on the other side and the fire spreads inside the ship Btw. why do you think that predeadnoughts and early dreadnoughts had no citadel? The citadel is a concept of 19th century. 1876: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HMS_Inflexible_(1876)

That was changed years ago...

I hope they will change that. Even Kongo has 19mm on Tier V as a BC. Amagi also has the standard bow playting and these are ships with a full gun layout. Repulse has already to sacrifice gunpower and belt armor for her speed.

It is unlikely she gets better plating that QE. But that is ok.

Winning gives 50% more XP, not matter if alive or sunk. Credits are not influenced by winning or being sunk.

I hope they do not give them inferior bow plating. One should at least be able to angle with them.

BC as a BB Tier VI now we need to know how they balance them (superior dispersion?, good rudder shift + concealment?, reload booster?)

I never did, just another thing you imagined. And when you think shooting HE at broadsides is the superior playstyle, then please continue doing it. Then let them fire HE at everything. It is their problem and my advantage. I do not need to hang back to deal with HE. see above Darting from cover to cover hardly allows you to solo a BB in a cruiser. That would take ages and it is unlikely that no other teammates get involved during that time. And if there is no other teammate in the area, the BB can point his guns in your direction wait till you show up. I am surprised how you get focussed by 6 invisible ships. The only time that happens to me is when some $%& friedly DD smokes up before me and does not spot and blocks the spotting for the whole friendly flank Takes a guess what warships are filled with and what HE shells do to people who try to fight fires...

Schaden und XP Kurven steigen schon in der Regel dadurch an indem man ein höheres Tier fährt.

I never claimed it does not happen to anyone. But in your dreamworld you read stuff that was never written.

choose your battles, take note where your and the enemies teammates are as they can change the outcome of a DD fight quickly, do not take on ships stronger than you, unless it is obvious you have help or have the advantage skill your guns on your torpboats, unless you plan to torp from max range, for good torp hits you need to get close to the target and there is usually an enemy DD between you and your target, gun skills help with dealing with the enemy dd train your aiming

Not everyone answers the questions like that. Even on a win I am sometimes less satisfied and there were losses which got a similar vote from me.

It does not matter which impression it creates. The effectivness matters. Let the uninformed spamm HE from max distance in every situation. As explained, angling still works and sniping is the inferiror tactic When you can spot the enemy, the enemy can hit you In most battles ships shot varied types ammunition. And during the battle of Tsushima, a lot of russian ships were lost to HE https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Tsushima#High_explosive_and_Cordite As explained HE penetrates. I do not recommend to sit behind 20mm of armored steel when a 120mm HE shells hits it on the other side. And yes, fire spread. They do not need to start near something sensitive, they will get there. That does not happen to me. Probably because I do not sit still to get farmed and I tend to disengage when I recognize in time that I cannot hold my position. I also tend to focus on targets closer than 20km and prefer to take them out first. But congratulations on explaning your lack of skill in the game

It is better to compare them with their peers than compare them with different Tiers. Z-31 Performancewise she looks surprisingly good. But I do not expect it to last. Playing her is a chore. To get to the CA and BB, you have to get through the enemy DD first and she has a hard time doing that. You are basicly nibbling on enemy DD until they are dead. Getting the finishing blow is often luck as your CA and BB do a lot more damage to the enemy and your nibbling gives them enough time to turn their turrets around. GJ Maerker Despite better DPM and more punch than Z-31, the problems become more obvious here. F. Schultz Now we are starting to enter Fantasy land and the performance improves a bit. Stil the core problem of dealing with enemy DD remains. Source http://maplesyrup.sweet.coocan.jp/wows/ranking/20210515/eu_2month/average_ship_u.html

Daher habe ich auch nicht Firefly geantwortet, sondern TorpedoTroll. Bitte nicht die Antworten und Zitate durcheinander bringen. Das geht über die Solo Siegrate sehr gut. Wer gar nicht solo unterwegs ist und nur Divi spielt entzieht sich einer Vergleichbarkeit. Bei Divisionsstats ist es unmöglich zu sagen welchen Anteil der Spieler selber hat und was seine Divisionskollegen geschafft haben. Da wir alle verschiedene Schiffe fahren, spielt die Schiffauswahl keine große Rolle. Wer nur bestimmte Schiffe fährt, für den können dann nur Aussagen zu diesen Schiffen getroffen werden Und die Kapitänskillung ist vollkommen irrelevant. Wer für seine Kapitäne eine schlechtere Auswahl trifft, zeigt nur damit seinen Mangel an Fähigkeiten. Die Karten spielen auch keine Rolle, da wir alle auf allen Karten fahren. Nach ein paar Tausend Gefechten spielt das keine Rolle mehr.