ColonelPete

Try to get rid of them before they reach you Most CV should be faster then Subs

The UK lost 2 DD and 2 Frigates + others ships in the Falkland War, it did not stop them. And that was a conflict heavily dependent on naval support. A single ship does not mean much for a land based conflict.

And if you have 67% winrate in her, where is the problem with the ship? Should she be stronger?

Then talk about math. Then check the numbers.

Nope. The chance is the result of your actions. Just clicking the battle button does not give you are 50% chance. You are talking about opportunity, not chance. Only when they are equally bad, which is rare.

You do not seem to understand that two possible outcomes does not result in a 50/50 chance. And yes, that is math.

WG never claimed they would not have a relation to Lesta, just that the company is not affiliated with WG.

Nope. That is not how this works. A bad player does not have a 50% chance, otherwise he would not be a bad player.

Then these bad players would have 50% winrating in 1v1. They do not.

As you said yourself, people play for different reasons and fun is relative. And your success depends on your skill level. Bad players get better results in 9v9 than in 1v1.

You could face off against an unicum in 1v1 too. And you said yourself, these extrem scenarios do not always happen and random teams can win against divisions and people have different objectives. It is your reasoning, not mine.

According to your reasoning, it is the same level of fairness. One could even argue that it is better, since you do not risk facing off solo against your counter class.

This way:

When you apply that reasoning, then brawls did not change at all.

What is fair in an 1v1 when a Cruiser without torps has to face off against a Melee BB?

Zum Beispiel. Ich dürfte bei 90% der Brawls nicht ein Gefecht gespielt haben.

Looks like somebody knows what he is talking about...

The game mode is made for divisions...

Which you they do not use, as you claimed.

Sure. That is why I have 100% winrate in some ships and 0% in others. Because it is all the same.

It can, alot. Team Size and Tier are changed often. Some people did not play Brawl before or only a few battles. Others play Brawls only in divisions. Some people use different ships and so on.

Then why did you refer us to the account and ship winratings, if you knew that WG uses Brawl Winratings?

What stats?

Yes, it can. It could be a Team Elo-Rating, which would be pretty useless for Random Teams, it could be number of wins in the current Brawl, which some players suspect. We just do not know for sure.

You have two unknowns on your team, so the overall winrate does not say much. Especially the color coding has absolutly nothing to do with the game. And it would be a first if WG used account winrating, which they obviously do not, considering other screenshots from Brawls.