mtm78

No one ever claimed otherwise, and to the rest; Ducat is sick, he should be ( and hopefully is atm ) in his bed getting better. I don't blame him for making a few mistakes in his posts. That is also why he probably didn't work out the first original thread in the first place, bad judgement well let's say yes to that shall we, but you're doing your very best to cling to anything which might stick? Do you really distrust him personally that much?

I was not downplaying the concerns from legitimate forum users, I also wasn't around when the thread was made so I only came into all this when it was already underway like a run away locomotive. This should have been handled differently, but it wasn't and nothing we say will change that. edit: And on the other hand, I still have to say that there is another side: imho some people here are very quick to jump the gun and that disappoints me a lot.

The same works in reverse, why are screenshots which don't proof he had a cheat installed on live server constituting to actual evidence according to some? Also I said for everyone to make up their own mind, that's literally what I said: watch and make up your own mind. edit: gramar

Well you should be able to watch the replay and if you know how the aimbot works you will likely be able to tell if the marker is consistently following the lead indicator but that is about as far as it goes I admit. Still, like I said he was 7 minutes in shooting a lot with 5 hits, that's not something I would expect from a cheat mod user. And that Mahan was sitting still when he got killed, not moving at all. Imho his explanation holds up with the character I know he possesses. I'm not one of the old ST guard so don't pin this on 'friendship' or 'closing rank', I'm saying this as another player and a member of this community. 3 posts, sleeper accounts are always a possibility

That comment made it seem to me you were on your usual ST bashing course yes. You continue now because you say we tend to be on a high horse about things. I can't talk for others but I was on a high horse before I got an ST tag I'm quite sure you wouldn't say otherwise yes? So how else to interpret your continued comments about what ST does or how well they do it? I'm not the one doing the projecting here, at least not the only one ( taking into account there is a possibility you're at least partially right ).

And you're credible how exactly? And sure you can now point to my ST tag and say I'm just defending my own but you're looking like nothing but a new account made to stir up some trouble. No it's worse, he was wrongly accused and tried to have some fun with it only to have it blow up in his face because people don't trust him enough to not cheat. Which shows the current state of community, as I said earlier and I know it's just my opinion but he is the last person I would be thinking off in relations with cheating and that only has in influence by my ST tag because that's how I know him. I would advise everyone to watch the replay and make up his/her own mind. That Mahan was so sure of his accusations that I would have posted on forum about it as well trying to both blow off some steam and to make some fun of it.

I must say, for a cheater that replay really shows how effective it would be 7 minutes in and he has 5 hits edit: I do hope people won't be as blind to think I just said he is cheating, but currently I'm not entirely sure edit2: and as he said that Mahan is just sitting still at close range ffs...

So I assume you already watched the replay?

You are, some others are not ( WW for example ). I fully agree this should be resolved transparently

Excuse me? Someone made a broad accusation against ST as a whole which I would like to see corrected and which has since been corrected. What is your agenda?

No, go back to the thread and specify it then. This is what I mean, you can't generalize like this.

Well I'm not even that interested in names specifically, I just wanted the broad accusation to be revoked. There is enough ST bashing going on, let's not make it worse then it already is.

Then at least we can agree it's not all of us, which leaves us with the fact that you broadly aimed the accusation at the whole of ST when this is not really warranted in any way?

Will you please specify what and who you mean with this accusation as I am quite sure I did not do any of the things which you claim I did. I've been objective and professional, and the ONLY time I said anything personal I made it very clear I was just stating my own opinion.

Meh I seen team killers yesterday, you can't stop a single team kill you can only hope to prevent people from doing it more often.

We need fully enabled training rooms ( aka WG sanctioned one's not the one available through modding ) and then we can set up something like STGA for WoWs. That will be the best way to get new players up to speed the quickest, because it can cater to a wide variety of skill sets.

That was in the part of my post you left out of your quote

Well let me rephrase: I have as much troubles hitting the citadel on a Nurnberg as an Aoba. I do agree those pictures look wrong period, but these things should be reported to proper channels and they should get corrected. Other ships have been lowered because they had the wrong depth. Either way I don't know if it would help, the thing with shooting Nurnberg's is that you can be head on and I will still citadel you ( or at angle ), while Aoba has a small chance to angle/deflect.

My Gremmy does worse than my Minekaze. My Murmansk has lower avg dmg then my OPmaha. My Imperator does only marginally better than my Arkansas Beta in win rate, but significantly better in damage. See, I'm not the guy you should ask about bias or not, my data doesn't fully support a 'bias' claim. But looking at averages it does look like investing in RU ships might be good for statwhoring ( not that that matters because we will be getting the ability to hide your relevant performance so everyone and their dog is suddenly capable of having a valid argument without others being able to show it's some 4x% wr noob who should keep his mouth shut and not give advice to others... wait wrong thread right.. sorry for that! ). Also this. Put good players against Imperator and the fight changes from seal clubbing to hard work. Especially USN BB's with proper angling can be really tough for Imperators guns. Luckily, in order to keep sailing Impregnator fun, most opposition never heard about broadsides it seems.

Did you play Michael Citadelovitch on PT? Did it seem OP? Maybe the first [edited] is coming

Again, if YOU think there is sufficient proof of wrongdoing then that might be a step you could decide to take. I'm not advocating anything, it's not anything I am concerned about. I know this will backfire but to be honest he is the LAST person I would suspect of cheating. He shouldn't need to, and frankly he is so relaxed about how he plays that cheating just doesn't fit the bill.

Hey I would rather see this resolved without a sliver of a doubt, either way it doesn't really affect me in any way other then WiskeyWolf implicating it makes the entire ST team look bad. And you're being reasonable, others are to, but some are not. I agree, this forum is not the place. If people are that disgruntled and are convinced they have proof of wrongdoing, I would advise you to take other measures then a witch hunt on this forum which both won't work but which also will heat things up beyond boiling point I am sure.

Well that would only happen at OP's own discretion now would it? This forum is not a tribunal, those powers are beyond us so please put down the pitchforks. Which leaves us again at effectiveness, where we seem to really disagree because you're the only one of us two which seems to think your modus operandi is the most efficient one to take. This forum is not the place this should be looked at, the community should never be allowed to self moderate as this will be abused eventually. I do however expect some 'civil unrest' if this is closed because people will suspect it's being 'shuffled under the rug' edit: No, you however did and then extended that to the entire ST team. Which as I showed, is beyond ludicrous.

So because I saw a beta tester admit he used the aimbot ages ago I can call every beta tester a cheater? Interesting Good terms might be stretching, but besides how you make your points I don't see much fault in you. That still leaves how you tend to make your points which is like... uhmm... edit2: btw which really helped was you being positive lately about what has been announced to be coming soon, if you're positive it can't be anything but a hit right

Hey their stickies for a reason ;)